| 30 candy | Common | 17.64 % |
| 50,000 coins | Common | 11.76 % |
| XP boost, 15 min | Common | 8.82 % |
| 80 candy | Uncommon | 7.84 % |
| Spooky Bag | Uncommon | 7.84 % |
| Void Key | Uncommon | 5.88 % |
| Shadow Key | Rare | 2.94 % |
| Halloween Key or 3 Spooky Bags | Rare | 1.96 % each |
| 300,000 coins, Candy Trail | Rare | 0.98 % each |
Pumpkin Head, Dragon Key, Pumpkin Minion I | Epic | 0.98 % each |
Chat colours Pumpkin Night and Witch Light | Epic | 0.25 % each |
| 500 candy | Legendary | 0.73 % |
| Pumpkin King title or 3 Halloween Keys | Legendary | 0.49 % each |
| Each accessory, Witch Hat | Legendary | 0.29 % each |
| 5 Halloween Keys | Legendary | 0.15 % |
| Empty spawner | Legendary | 0.05 % |
| Halloween egg: spider, snow golem or bat | Legendary | 0.04 % each |
| Each Lantern Warden piece | Mythic | 0.15 % each |
| Each Pumpkin Harvester tool | Mythic | 0.10 % each |
| Terrapex | Mythic | 0.05 % |
Lantern Warden full set, Spawner Breaker V | Mythic | 0.04 % each |
Halloween spawner: snow golem, bat or random mob | Mythic | 0.01 % each |
| Zombie or Skeleton Spawner | Mythic | 0.01 % each |